Back to Blog Academy

The Best OBD Scanner for Diagnosing Transmission Issues

By Joe Ballard
Published on October 21st, 2024

As an Amazon associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Besides the engine, the transmission is your vehicle's second most important mechanical component. Without a manual or automatic transmission, you and your vehicle are not going anywhere. For the most part, your transmission is very reliable, but problems can develop, such as slipping (most common), not smoothly shifting gears, or not staying in gear as you drive.

The Best OBD Scanner for Diagnosing Transmission Issues

For an automatic transmission, these signs can indicate internal damage or the transmission fluid is low. There could be other issues with manual transmission, such as a bad clutch plate, failing throw-out bearing, or low fluid in the hydraulic clutch cylinder.

In this article, I will focus on automatic transmissions and provide you with an overview of how they work, the warning signs of a failing transmission, how to diagnose and fix transmission issues before the damage compounds, and how the cost of repair increases. By actively maintaining your vehicle's transmission system, you can save significant amounts of money on costly repairs, which should motivate and encourage you to be proactive.

How does a transmission work?

At the heart of an automatic transmission lies a fascinating component-the torque converter. This ingenious device allows your vehicle to shift gears seamlessly, without any intervention from you. While most transmissions have four or five gears, some newer models boast as many as ten. This type of gearbox operates using a transmission fluid coupling, with a reservoir of transmission fluid serving as its lifeblood. The complexity and sophistication of this system is truly intriguing, isn't it? It's like a well-orchestrated symphony of mechanical parts working in perfect harmony, inviting your curiosity and interest.

Modern transmissions are controlled by a computer, which selects the correct gear based on inputs from various sensors located around the vehicle. This advanced system often includes an overdrive gear designed to improve fuel economy by reducing engine drag at high speeds. While these technological advancements enhance your vehicle's performance and efficiency, they can also increase ownership costs, especially as the transmission ages.

How does a transmission work

Let’s take a deeper dive into the various components that make the transmission tick:

  • Transmission fluid is the heart and soul of the transmission. All of its internal components depend on the constant flow of the fluid. For this reason, it is important to ensure that the fluid level is maintained and that it does not break down as it ages. A quart of fluid typically costs $8 - $20.
  • The transmission solenoid is an electromagnetic component that controls the fluid flow throughout the transmission. If it malfunctions, fluid may not reach the critical components inside the transmission, which could lead to operating issues. The typical cost to replace a solenoid is $500.
  • Transmission bands link the internal gears together to ensure the transmission will not slip. As the bands age, they begin to have wear and tear and other damage that could cause the transmission to slip. The typical cost to replace the bands is $1,500.
  • The torque converter converts the power from the engine into torque, which the transmission uses to turn the drive wheels and propel the vehicle forward. This is the most critical transmission component, so it is important to protect it by ensuring that the fluid level is correct. If you notice issues like smoking or jumping gears, the torque converter could be the culprit. The typical cost to replace a converter is $1000.

Based on the costs associated with the various components of the transmission, there are a few simple things you can do regularly to identify potential issues and take corrective action. These include checking the fluid level and making sure it is in range. If you see some purple-colored fluid under your vehicle and need to add fluid frequently, you probably have a transmission fluid leak. The other check you can do is run the transmission temperature test using an OBD scanner. This will tell you if the fluid is within the normal operating range, as a high temperature indicates the fluid level is low or is not circulating efficiently.

Find the perfect scanner in 1 minute

What are the warning signs?

Several tell-tale signs of a transmission issue include engine chugging or revving, weak acceleration, improperly shifting gears, strange grinding noises or whining, an odd burning smell, and the dreaded CEL. Many of these issues will result in the transmission slipping, which could become a safety issue if not addressed promptly.

Let’s take a closer look at the warning signs of a slipping transmission:

  • The vehicle feels sluggish and is slow to accelerate, which could indicate that the bands are worn or the transmission is low on fluid.
  • The vehicle revs loudly, and RPM exceeds 3500 after you put it in gear and press the gas pedal. This is a sure sign of worn bands or low fluid.
  • The vehicle suddenly shifts into neutral, which could indicate an issue with the transmission controller.
  • The most common indication of a transmission issue is the vehicle making noises or vibrating with the unmistakable sound of grinding gears.
  • The “Transmission Hot Idle Engine" light comes on, which may indicate a failing solenoid or low transmission fluid.
  • CEL comes on, which means that the transmission temperature sensor detected overheating and has sent a code to the ECU.

Key Takeaways

Adhering to a regular maintenance schedule is very important. As I have said in previous articles, this is the easiest way to avoid many problems. If you can identify a simple problem like low transmission fluid early enough, you can avoid a costly transmission repair involving the torque converter or other expensive components. Regular maintenance using an OBD scanner will also identify a malfunctioning component before it impacts the vehicle's performance and the safety of you and your passengers.

Innova 5610 paired with RepairSolutions2

As a DIYer, you know that the best course of action to identify the specific problem is to utilize an OBD scanner. Using my 2019 Hyundai Ioniq as an example, I connected the Innova 5610 scanner and the RepairSolutions2 app to perform several transmission-related tests. Unfortunately, the transmission temperature is not supported by the Ioniq ECU; however, the Transmission Live Data test is available to check the transmission. To verify which tests are supported by your vehicle, simply run the coverage checker tool that is located on the Innova website. It will provide you with a list of tests that are supported so that you can proactively scan systems to ensure all parameters are within range. Combining the OBD scanner with the Innova RepairSolutions 2 tool will enable you to identify any problems and show you the estimated costs to replace the component.

Conclusion

Proactively identifying and addressing issues impacting your vehicle will ensure you are not caught in a dangerous situation. Using tools like the OBD scanner and observing sights, smells, and sounds that don’t seem right will also help prevent minor issues from getting larger and becoming more costly to repair. A transmission is a complicated piece of machinery, but with a little effort, you can ensure that it lasts the life of your vehicle.

Back to Blog Academy

Explore Our Products

Innova 5610.png__PID:25b1434d-0da5-4c75-9e00-53f775f17ffd

OBD2 Handheld Scanners

Innova 1000 Dongle Render 7-8-2024.9 2 (5).png__PID:f7f46533-efbd-45f6-840d-97fd954ee238

OBD2 Bluetooth Scanners

Innova 1000 Dongle Render 7-8-2024.9 2 (5).png__PID:f7f46533-efbd-45f6-840d-97fd954ee238

OBD2 Tablet Scanners

05-0005_top 7.png__PID:6d6168a2-e747-4422-a97a-8763b9887396

OBD1 Tools

3340a_Main_Image_Front_Final (1) 2.png__PID:91e1e192-4adf-4d55-8f90-f2d9651f6458

Multimeters

3361_blue_240215-1183x2789-75c92773-54bb-4ee9-bfff-28c25483c339 2 (1).png__PID:d9651f64-5811-4038-8825-d1146b14e94e

Inspection Cameras

View All Products

Have Questions?

Hop in the discussion board on our community site!
It's a place where we help each other answer questions. Like Reddit but for automotive lovers.

Visit Community